• Deadly outbreak of TB because of doctor's misdiagnosis
Deadly outbreak of TB because of doctor's misdiagnosis
27 Mar, 2017, 1 Comment

Summary: A DEADLY outbreak of drug-resistant tuberculosis has occurred in Australia because a Sydney doctor wrongly diagnosed a 23-year-old university student with asthma and then lung cancer before realising it was TB.....

An investigation by News Corp Australia has uncovered a further 10 people were infected by the disease after the man tried to get treatment from his GP and only after his third return visit — and three months of sickness — was referred for an X-ray which uncovered a 6cm hole in his lung.

Patient Zero was told by his Chippendale-based GP that his persistent cough, shortness of breath and general malaise was likely lung cancer and sent immediately to Royal Prince Alfred Hospital on October 21 where tests confirmed he was suffering from a slightly drug resistant strain of tuberculosis.

By that stage the Sydney University graduate was highly contagious due to his misdiagnosis and he had already infected 10 people.

Tuberculosis is a slow growing bacteria and the longer a patient goes without treatment the more infectious they are.

The latest bungle by a NSW doctor highlights a farcical health system plagued by problems.

It follows months of screw ups by our health professionals including:

* The deaths of two newborn babies who were given the wrong gas at Bankstown-Lidcome Hospital;

* A fake Indian doctor who allegedly worked under false documentation in a number of Sydney hospitals and;

* The case of a St Vincent’s Hospital oncologist who gave a lower dosage of chemo drugs than recommended to patients.

The collective scandals ultimately led to the resignation of former health minister Jillian Skinner last month.

And the federal Health Department has issued a slapdown to NSW over the handling of the case.

“TB is a nationally notifiable disease which means that there is enhanced surveillance by the Commonwealth and states and territories,” a spokeswoman for the federal health department told News Corp Australia.

“Regarding the NSW case, the Federal Department of Health will be following up with NSW Health. The issue of whether there needs to be further education of health professionals about TB, will also be raised with the Communicable Diseases Network of Australia (CDNA).”


News Corp Australia has chosen not to reveal the identity of Patient Zero to protect his privacy amid fears he will be stigmatised or not be able to find work as a result of his TB diagnosis.

Patient Zero was placed in isolation at RPA for three weeks and then spent a further eight weeks in isolation at home.

He is still on 16.5 antibiotics a day and has to present to hospital each weekday morning to receive his drugs which he will take for a total of nine months.

Those who contracted the disease off him are either also on antibiotics or under monitoring by their local chest clinics for up to two years.

“I just felt like I had a really bad flu that wouldn’t go away,” Patient Zero told News Corp Australia.

“I was otherwise still myself and was even surfing three times a week.”

Patient Zero said he likely picked up the disease while backpacking in Morocco, Vietnam, Cambodia Bali and Thailand.

He said doctors told him he was one of the only non-refugee cases they had seen of TB in a long time.

Patient Zero was petrified to discuss his case openly for fear of persecution.

“I just don’t want people to work out that it was me who was sick with this.”

He said those infected included members of his family but also people he worked and studied with.

Tuberculosis is a highly infectious airborne disease caused by a bacterial infection. It can damage a person’s lungs or other parts of the body and cause serious illness or death.

Around 1300 cases of TB are diagnosed in Australia each year, however drug resistant strains are rare.

It kills 1.8 million people a year and is the biggest single disease killer in the Asia-Pacific region.


Vicky Sheppeard, Director of Communicable Diseases at NSW Health denied there had been an “outbreak” of TB.

“Public announcements about people with TB disease are rarely necessary as TB is

not spread by brief, casual exposures,” Dr Sheppeard said.

“NSW has one of the lowest rates of TB in the world.”

Dr Sheppeard said TB should be suspected in people with persistent coughs longer than three weeks.

But she said there was no current investigation into the doctor’s misdiagnosis because a “complaint” had not yet been made.

Michael Gannon, president of the Australian Medical Assoiciation said doctors needed to keep TB front and mind when seeing patients with a persistent cough.

“Its incidence is on the rise around the world and it is very important it remains in the differential diagnosis,” Dr Gannon said.

“We underestimate it at our peril.”

Patient Zero’s story comes as Australian tuberculosis experts warn a lack of funding for TB research could result in a doubling of cases in Australia in the next five years and potentially the introduction of more drug-resistant cases.

The Tuberculosis Centre for Research Excellence is due to run out of funding at the end of the year.

Gabriella Scandurra executive officer for the TBCRE said TB was a “real threat” for Australians without continued research into how best to treat the disease.

“It will only be a matter of time until the numbers shoot up because we’re going to have more Australian travellers coming back with TB,” Dr Scandurra said.

“This is just a ticking time bomb and it is going to be a complete economic catastrophe for Australia if we have more drug resistant strains because the cost of keeping people in isolation is astronomical.”

news.com.au 27/3/17

  • MyPassion

    12 Apr, 2017

    I want to know what is being done about blacks entering our schools as there families are the TB carriers and our kids are being exposed to this sickness even after having all their vaccinations they are not immunised against TB.
Leave a reply.
I want to post anonymously.
I want to use my alias.
Would you like to be notified of new comments to this News Thread?           
Yes, email me as new comments are added